Main Lesson | Sect A | Sect B | Sect C | Sect D | Sect E | Sect F | Sect H

G.  PROOF OF CALCULUS METHOD
 
[This Section is best taught by the teacher. You may want to look at Section H first.]
 
1. How do you prove that the definite integral gives the area under a curve? We use the Riemann Sums for very large n (or for very small x, i.e. as x0). This shows the link between the numerical methods and the calculus method.
 
2. Consider the diagram in the Worksheet. P(x, y) and Q(x+x, y+y) are 2 points on the curve near to each other.
From Question 10, LowerSum < Area < UpperSum. Thus
Area of Rectangle PSRU < Area Under Curve < Area of Rectangle TSRQ
PS x SR < A < TS x SR
          yx < A < (y+y)x
        y < < y+y
As x0, y0.
So , which is bounded by lower limit y and upper limit y+ y, has to become y as x0.
Therefore  y as x0, i.e.  = y.
But you have learnt in Differentiation IT Lesson 1 - Gradient Function that .
Therefore  = y, i.e. if you differentiate the area A under a curve, you get the equation y of the curve!
 
3. Recall that integration is the reverse of differentiation, i.e.  = y'   y = .
Therefore  = y   A = .
Recall the definition of the definite integrals which say that [F(x)] = f(x)   = F(b) – F(a).
Now area under a curve from x = a to x = b is given by A(b) – A(a) where we treat A as a function.
Therefore area under a curve from x = a to x = b is A(b) – A(a) = ,
i.e. if you integrate the equation y of a curve from x = a to x = b, you get the area under the curve!
 
 
4. From Sect E para 5, the Riemann Sum (yx)  A as x0.
Since A = , then (yx)   as x0,
i.e. the Riemann Sum (yx) becomes the definite integral  as x0 (or as n becomes bigger).
This is the link between the numerical methods and the calculus method. The integral, as defined in this way, is called the Riemann integral. For info, there are integrals defined in other ways.
 
5. It is important to note that the definite integral is a limit, just like the derivative (or the gradient function).
 
 
6. Now that we have learnt the calculus method, what is the use of the numerical methods? 
(a)  Many expressions cannot be integrated, e.g. sin x2. So you still need the numerical methods to approximate the definite integral.
(b) It will take a long time to integrate complicated expressions (which can be integrated). In such cases, LiveMath will ask you whether to proceed with the integration or to use a numerical method which is still faster.
(c) LiveMath is a computer algebra system (CAS), unlike most other software. It can perform algebraic operations like factorisation, differentiation and integration. Non-CAS will use a numerical method to find the answers.
 
 
H.  WHO WAS RIEMANN? (ENRICHMENT)
 
Continue Lesson - Bernhard Riemann

 
Main Lesson | Sect A | Sect B | Sect C | Sect D | Sect E | Sect F | Sect H